Âé¶ą´«Ă˝

Skip to main content
Underground mining equipment

The hidden solutions driving underground mining productivity

Discover why a mindset shift around lubricant and maintenance programmes is needed to help underground miners meet their operational targets, now and in the future. Our expert Q&A digs deeper to find out.

As the demand for greater energy consumption and economic development grows, so does the demand for critical materials and commodities. And, for those who descend into the depths of the Earth in search of those materials, this means digging deeper. With the toll this can take on workers and their equipment, it has the potential to make one of the most challenging jobs in the world harder.

Augusto Fernandes, Product Application Specialist – Mining Americas, and Michael Longbottom, Global LubeExpert Coach, Shell Lubricant Solutions, bring new perspectives on how underground miners can meet growing demand by reaching new levels of productivity – unlocking performance improvements through effective lubrication, equipment maintenance and hands on services.

Augusto Fernandes

Augusto Fernandes

With almost 30 years industry experience, Augusto uses his extensive lubrication expertise to help miners in South and North America improve productivity and profitability across their sites by implementing effective lubrication programmes that help to reduce total cost of ownership (TCO).

Headshot of Micheal Longbottom

Michael Longbottom

With over 36 years in mining, Michael leads the global standardisation of Shell LubeExpert - embedding best practices and delivering an offering which provides the mining sector with a team of technicians dedicated to maintaining lubrication systems to drive equipment performance.

What are the specific challenges for underground miners?

Michael Longbottom: There are a range of challenges in underground mining that are specific to underground and uncommon in open pit mines. Firstly, underground mine shafts are hot and humid. This means that ventilation and the continuous circulation of quantity and quality of air is a priority (as is providing the energy to power this). You can’t send people and equipment down into the mine without that in place.

On the equipment side, it’s easy to envisage the huge excavators and haulers used by open pit mines, but underground it’s a bit different. Equipment is much smaller because it must be to navigate the narrow tunnels. With a wider variety of machines on site, there’s greater potential for faults and failures for maintenance teams to manage. It’s also hard to supervise mining operations deep underground. From a maintenance perspective, there’s no easy way to access these mines, which can open the door to poor maintenance practices which can lead to equipment breakdowns.

Augusto Fernandes: As Michael says, deep mines present new challenges for the miners digging them. The deeper the tunnels reach, the higher the temperature at which people and equipment must operate, which in turn increases the operational challenges. It is why ventilation is critical – and why effective equipment maintenance shouldn’t be overlooked. Inadequate or insufficient maintenance practices can lead to increased downtime and the unsafe operation of equipment, putting both safety and productivity at risk.

What impact do these have on the equipment?

AF: The environment and conditions in underground mining can be a significant challenge for machines and the lubricants protecting them. The type of rock being mined (hard or soft) and heat can make a significant difference. When you increase the temperature, the risk of leaks and contamination of the lubricants becomes greater. You’re likely to see a negative impact on the performance of the lubricants in use, leading to reduced equipment productivity.

ML: Because of the harsh conditions in underground mining, equipment life is shorter than it would be in an open pit mine. This leads to more repairs and replacements – increasing unplanned downtime and maintenance costs. The presence of water and humidity in underground mining increases the risk of contamination and corrosion (as well as lubricant washout) while lower oxygen levels place greater stress on components, causing increased wear.

We also shouldn’t ignore the fact that it’s often harder for maintenance teams to access broken down equipment, making repairs take longer. The diversity of equipment in use also makes it difficult to standardise maintenance practices across a site.

Lit up underground mine

Given the equipment challenges, why is lubrication often underestimated?

ML: Lubricants may not be a priority for underground miners which can make conversations on the topic challenging. Cost is understandably a critical factor for miners and there’s usually a preference for cheaper products, but these often don’t provide a solution to the challenge - they can often exacerbate things. Our role as lubricant experts is to help underground miners understand how higher performance products and best practice services can continuously help miners meet their performance and profitability goals by achieving higher productivity.

AF: Lubricants are often perceived as a consumable, or a cost, not as an asset by underground miners. And when underground miners do look at their supply of lubricants, reducing purchasing costs quickly becomes the focus. But we see that as the tip of the iceberg when it comes to the total cost of maintenance. The cost of lubricant products is significantly outweighed by the cost that comes with using them ineffectively. In other words, quick, short-term and one-off gains (reduced purchasing costs of lubricants) incur much higher losses year on year.

The shortened lifecycle of underground mining equipment means there’s an opportunity for quality lubricants and lubrication best practices to deliver significant productivity gains by making the most of – and even extending – that lifecycle. Small changes within mining maintenance practices can compound and have a big impact on operations overall. That’s why we work to equip underground miners with the right knowledge about lubricants and lubrication management.

“With the focus on reducing the cost of consumables, you could ask why high-tier products in underground mining. But we’ve had many success stories where customers have made cost savings and increased productivity through a combination of high quality lubricants and services.”

Michael Longbottom, Global LubeExpert Coach, Shell Lubricant Solutions

How do you shift that mindset and show miners the value of high performance lubricants?

AF: For me, audits and site assessments are vital. They allow you to get a closer look at what’s happening on the ground with the equipment, the lubricant and overall maintenance practices. This makes it easier to identify any barriers to productivity and make recommendations designed to deliver tangible cost savings and added business value.

The recommendations we make include overarching concepts like preventive maintenance – which can help to avoid unplanned downtime, therefore reducing operating costs and improving productivity. We also see training on how to improve the standard of lubrication and get the most from high performance consumables as essential. This sits alongside the use of services like Shell LubeAnalyst and Shell RemoteSense, which enable site teams to make further productivity gains through effective predictive maintenance management. Ultimately, if you can work with the miner to jointly demonstrate the value of your approach, you can begin to shift the mindset.

ML: Another challenge we face in this area is the turnover in site management. You’ll often see someone new come into the business who has a renewed focus on cost reduction and doesn’t see the immediate or ongoing value of using the right lubricant and lubrication programmes.

It’s why, as Augusto said, you need to keep demonstrating the value of high performance lubricants and lubrication best practices to avoid good intentions (cost optimisation) leading to unsuccessful outcome (higher costs, downtime and productivity losses).

What steps can miners take to realise the value of their maintenance programmes?

Underground mine

ML: If you want to improve the endurance (and lifetime) of your equipment, it’s not a case of simply selecting a range of high performance lubricants. There’s little point in adopting such products if you can’t see their full value, which means there are some key elements that need to be in place first. This includes how you manage the fluids in use across your site (what we call total fluid management) and how you dispense those fluids effectively.

Then you consider how contamination and temperature is controlled, as well as the training and best practices implented by site teams You should also have a clear idea of your machine specifications and their applications, so your products and practices best meet your equipment needs.

AF: Picking up on the total fluid management element, an important part of this is monitoring lubricant and equipment performance. This is where services like Shell LubeExpert can help – giving miners access to on-site experts who support with inspections and servicing, as well as identifying opportunities for preventive maintenance and cost savings. It’s all about maximising the impact of high performance lubricants to drive site productivity.

“There’s an opportunity for underground mining to learn from the mindset of open pit mines – focusing on performance and total cost of ownership instead of up-front costs, which are the tip of the iceberg.”

Augusto Fernandes, Product Application Specialist – Mining Americas, Shell

How to go beyond surface-level thinking

Just as underground miners need to dig deeper to meet society’s growing demand for critical materials, they also need to look beyond the tip of the iceberg that the purchasing cost of lubricants represent if they want to achieve their commercial goals.

Understanding the full impact of lubricants – and in turn choosing the right lubricant and having the right total fluid management programme – can help miners turn what they often see as nothing more than a cost and a consumable into a valuable solution that reduces their total cost of operations while delivering significant efficiency and productivity gains.

Breaking New Ground: Beneath the Surface

Our latest whitepaper, based on in-depth discussions with underground mining decision-makers, explores how underground miners can unlock opportunities by tapping into expert technical support and the latest innovations in lubrication management.

Download the whitepaper (PDF, 10 MB)

 

Mock-up of the breaking new ground whitepaper